CD Mastering Services
Celebrating Our 27th Year Of Serving The Music Industry 1985-2012
High-End Processing... Analog Warmth / Digital Precision
Logo
 
how to Identify mastering scams
By Bob Speer

The purpose of this article isn't to condemn all facilities that charge cheap prices.  The market place will always have its various price points no matter what the product is.  Consumers are always free to choose whatever they perceive to be a good value. However, mastering is like any other product or service.  You get what you pay for.  When choosing a mastering facility that charges cheap rates, you run the risk of becoming the victim of a scam.  The search engines are full of them.  They attract customers with marketing hype, cheap rates, and provide masters of questionable quality.  So, it's "buyer beware."

Digital technology has enabled anyone with a computer and inexpensive or cracked software, to enter the mastering arena.
There are common phrases used by scam mastering facilities that should raise a red flag whenever you're using an Internet search engine, or reading advertisements in music publications.  You need to exercise caution when obtaining the services of any facility that uses these phrases.  Being aware of these phrases will help you identify the scams so you don't become their next victim.

Examples of common phrases are:

  1. We're The Cheapest... And The Best.
  2. We Make Your Music Sound Amazing.
  3. Mastering - Only $15 Per Track.
  4. Mastering - Only $199 For A Complete CD.
  5. We Provide CDs That Are Radio Ready (Or Advertise Radio Quality Results).
  6. We Offer 24 Hour Turn Around (48 Hour Turn Around Is Also Common).
  7. Have Your CD Mastered By One Of Our Expert Engineers.
  8. We Make Your Music Loud And Punchy.
  9. Before And After Mastering Samples.
10. If You Don't Like It... You Don't Pay.

Again, these are just examples.  The actual phrases might be slightly different from the above, but the scam is still the same.

Let's examine each of the above phrases.

We're The Cheapest... And The Best
It's interesting how some mastering engineers openly admit how little their mastering talent is worth.  In looking at their gear
list, they claim to have thousands of dollars invested in equipment.  They never mention their mastering room which costs thousands of dollars to design and build.  Can they really make money charging $15.00 a track, or $199.00 for a whole CD if they have to pay for their investment and facilities overhead?  The level of service these facilities provide should be obvious.

We Make Your Music Sound Amazing
This statement takes advantage of those who don't know what to expect when having their CD mastered.  Here's a good rule to follow.  If your mix doesn't already sound good to you when you're finished mixing, it's not ready to be mastered.

Mastering - Only $15 Per Track
The same answer as "We're The Cheapest... And The Best."

Mastering - Only $199 For A Complete CD
Also the same answer as "We're The Cheapest... And The Best."

We Provide CDs That Are Radio Ready
Radio ready is a myth that got started through misinformation, then advanced through ignorance.  It usually means the music has to be mastered loud to sound good on the radio.  Nothing can be further from the truth.  This
Article written by Bob Orban, the man who invented the radio compressor, is very revealing in regards to radio broadcast levels and how they affect music.

We Offer 24 Hour Turn Around
It takes 6 to 8 hours (depending on the material) to master the average 10 to 12 song CD.  So how can a mastering facility
offer a 24 hour turn around if they're as busy as they try to make you think they are?  They turn a project around fast because they have the misguided idea that mastering means one thing... make it loud.  They slap a brick wall limiter on the tracks, raise the level 6 to 10dB, and they're done in minutes (that's why the cheap price).  However, that's not mastering.  It's "messtering."

Have Your CD Mastered By One Of Our Expert Engineers
What's funny is they never mention who the expert engineers are.  Never have a CD mastered without knowing who the so called "expert engineer" is.  Not telling you the name of the engineer is unprofessional and shows a lack of common courtesy. Or, it means they're hiding something from you.

We Make Your Music Loud And Punchy
This is complete nonsense!  For a mix to be both loud and punchy is to defy the law of physics.  It has to be one or the other. This statement shows a lack of audio integrity.  A mix with punch requires headroom which results in a lower volume.  For a
mix to be loud, the headroom must be removed or drastically reduced, which eliminates the punch.  It's not rocket science.

Before And After Mastering Samples
While there are some legitimate mastering facilities that offer before and after samples, be careful of this one.  It's common
for some mastering facilities to first master a song, then go back to the original and EQ it to sound worse than it did originally. Then they lower the level of the original by 3-4dB to make it sound even weaker in comparison.  Then they post both versions on their web site so you can listen to the huge differences.  This is dishonest, unethical, and it's happening more than you think.

If You Don't Like It... You Don't Pay
They lure you in by using this tactic.  It sounds safe, doesn't it.  If you think about it for a minute, what does this really say?
It says they have a lack of confidence in their ability and have the expectation that you may not like their work.  Legitimate mastering facilities don't operate in this manner.  They don't offer a "don't pay" policy because an engineer, like anyone else providing a service, should be paid for his time.  Legitimate mastering facilities don't expect you to feel their work is mediocre.

To Summarize
Be careful when considering a facility as described in the 10 points above, and use caution with facilities whose web sites are full of marketing hype.  Who you choose to master your project is entirely up to you.  There are many facilities to choose from at various price points.  Be careful of those who try to lure you in with cheap rates.  Cheap rates aren't necessarily an indication that a facility is operating as a scam, but most scam operations charge cheap rates.  So be forewarned.  It may help you avoid
a major disappointment.

 
Enhance The Presentation Of Your Mix So It Sounds Its Best On The Widest Variety Of Playback Systems
Copyright 2001-2012 All Rights Reserved
CD Mastering Services